From With This Ring Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(SPOILERS)
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 39: Line 39:
 
----
 
----
  
I think it might be best to have the canon list of JL members at the story start. Then Paragon & Renegade lists of all confirmed members, and finally have the 'future' members be listed in a separate 'Word Of Zoat' page, in case the line-up changes. -- [[User:Earlyriser3|Earlyriser]] ([[User:Earlyriser3|talk]]) Jan 18
+
I think it might be best to have the canon list of JL members at the story start. Then Paragon & Renegade lists of all confirmed members, and finally have the 'future' members be listed in a separate 'Word Of Zoat' page, in case the line-up changes. -- [[User:Earlyriser3|Earlyriser3]] ([[User:Earlyriser3|talk]]) Jan 18
  
 
== Does Grayven belong in the "Crisis on Infinite Pauls" section? ==
 
== Does Grayven belong in the "Crisis on Infinite Pauls" section? ==
Line 48: Line 48:
  
 
Personally I agree with shotiegun11 here. The name of the section is just a silly joke; it's really a sub-index of alternate Pauls. [[User:Coda|Coda]] ([[User talk:Coda|talk]]) 20:20, 16 January 2018 (CST)
 
Personally I agree with shotiegun11 here. The name of the section is just a silly joke; it's really a sub-index of alternate Pauls. [[User:Coda|Coda]] ([[User talk:Coda|talk]]) 20:20, 16 January 2018 (CST)
 +
 +
== Should there be separate pages for the Renegade versions of characters, or just a section on their page to indicate the differences? ==
 +
Alan Scott is a little less Blue and a lot more ''dead'' in the Renegade side of things, and some other characters have had a lot of other significant changes throughout the story. Perhaps we should have separate character pages? -- [[User:Sceptic|Sceptic]] ([[User talk:Sceptic|talk]]) 02:55, 29 January 2018 (CST)

Latest revision as of 02:55, 29 January 2018

SPOILERS

I vote that spoilers should be allowed, the wiki is for organising information on everything in the WTR universe.


Future TEAM Members:

  • B19 - Osiris (I don't think she has been shown yet)
  • B20
    • Starfire (it did not test well)
    • Red Star (Leonid Kovar)
  • B21 - Supergirl
  • B22 - Star Sapphire (Ghia'ta)
  • B23 - Green Lantern (Arisia Raab)


Future LEAUGE Members:

  • 24 - Blue Lantern (Alan Scott)
  • 25 - Doctor Mist (Nommo Balewa) (Again, not shown)
  • 26 - Red Rocket (Dmitri Pushkin)
  • 27 – Blaze (Angelica Blaze) (I think she was shown)

So out of the future cast, at most 3 of them don't need a page yet, the rest do and most are more or less guarantees. --Jcc10 (talk) 00:45, 6 January 2018 (CST)


(I have no idea how this forum style is supposed to work) I, Empiricist, disagree. If the wiki supports spoiler tags that require user interaction to view, then it's acceptable for the information to be included. It would save Zoat needing to be asked every once in a while. But if someone who has read all cuurent updates but doesn't want to spoil future plot points wants to reference knowledge here, they shouldn't have to cover their eyes to look at the current Team roster. Furthermore, until a spoiler policy is decided I think it is in bad form to include said spoilers in such a publically viewable manner. As I said in the thread, I don't think it's generally a good policy to include information as factual before it has been written yet. Zoat could very well decide to change something, and he is under no obligation to tell anyone. The wiki would then be misleading. PLEASE SIGN POSTS WITH --~~~~


While I do agree that there needs to be some standard, at the same time it would be nice for people to not have to hunt down the last time he posted a list.

The best long term solution would be for a proper spoiler plugin such as [1], however...

would this work for now?

--Jcc10 (talk) 01:25, 6 January 2018 (CST) Edited:--Jcc10 (talk) 01:39, 6 January 2018 (CST)


I think it might be best to have the canon list of JL members at the story start. Then Paragon & Renegade lists of all confirmed members, and finally have the 'future' members be listed in a separate 'Word Of Zoat' page, in case the line-up changes. -- Earlyriser3 (talk) Jan 18

Does Grayven belong in the "Crisis on Infinite Pauls" section?

(Was he in the infinite earths story line?) -Jcc10

(Because he's an alternate Paul) -shotiegun11

Personally I agree with shotiegun11 here. The name of the section is just a silly joke; it's really a sub-index of alternate Pauls. Coda (talk) 20:20, 16 January 2018 (CST)

Should there be separate pages for the Renegade versions of characters, or just a section on their page to indicate the differences?

Alan Scott is a little less Blue and a lot more dead in the Renegade side of things, and some other characters have had a lot of other significant changes throughout the story. Perhaps we should have separate character pages? -- Sceptic (talk) 02:55, 29 January 2018 (CST)